Validation and Verification

Are you a Systems Engineer? Are you sick and tired of hearing about Verification and Validation (V&V) that you would puke the next time you hear it? Then stop reading this because I am just going to repeat what you’ve probably known.

The axioms are Validation is doing the right thing while Verification is doing the thing right. I find this confusing as English is not my mother tongue and the tongue twister of putting the word ‘right’ at the right place is, confusing. Another way is that people say Validation is only at the start and Verification is throughout the project, which I think is true, as V&V report is normally done at phase 1 and phase 7, or the last phase, as per BS EN 5012X (or other IEC 61508 derivatives) but what happens if the phase is more than 7 phases? Or less. Easy some people might say, verification just happens along the V while validation happens ‘across’ the V. Yeah I’ve used this explanation too but it’s not very clear.

I’ve come up with this analogy, where let’s say you are a baker. A customer asks for a cake, which you then bake according to a recipe. When you check whether you are following the recipe, that is verification. Recipe = Verification. Verecipefication. Voila!

Then you give the cake to the customer. After he/she ate the cake, then it is validATEd. Get it?

The end. Now I’ll stop talking about V&V.

Thank you for reading.

Similar Posts

  • Learning from Accidents

    Recently the study group I joined was talking about minor accidents and it was a good exercise to go through these cases reported by Rail Accident and Investigation Branch (RAIB), because these accidents most of the time are caused by similar underlying causes, and in left unchecked, will cause more serious accidents. If we look…

  • Spoken vs Written Speech

    I think I”ve written this book before but I felt like writing it again, as I recently joined a webinar which was about Railway and Systems Engineering. The presentation was full of interesting points and the slides were well made. There were diagrams drawn or excerpts from papers that explain complex concepts in simple summaries,…

  • |

    Cybersecurity and Aikido

    Disclaimer: I am neither a cybersecurity expert nor an Aikido practitioner so apologies in advance for any faux pas or false facts. I was watching this video recently where it interviews an Aikido masters and he talked about Iai (Iaido), where one is always prepared to draw their sword due to sudden attack, which relates…

  • Cake Analogy Again

    I was in a meeting today when I described a process using a cake analogy, again, and most of my colleagues looked at me in askance. I think I should try using other analogies other than a cake analogy. The thing is though I like cake and I think most people have eaten cake, even…

  • Manager and Boss

    I saw a post on LinkedIn today telling how a person who got a 45% increase in salary and a lot of benefits such as working remotely, left the company, after being called useless and exposed to toxic environment and management. The post then went on to say that people left not because of the…

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *